Black and white photo of a person in a leather jacket against a wall holding a phone, with the informed.now logo and the words news without noise

Perspectives

Do we deserve the right to be informed?

The 78 countries that wrote a right to information into their constitutions score no freer on Freedom House's scale than the 63 that didn't. Chuck Black looks at the Fairness Doctrine, hate speech laws, and those constitutional clauses, and argues that a legal right to be informed wouldn't produce informed citizens.

· 8 min read

Summary: No Western democracy treats being informed as a civil right. The 78 countries with a constitutional right to information score no freer than the countries without one. Chuck Black argues that writing that right into law wouldn't make citizens more informed.

This is the second part of a 2-part Perspectives series by informed.now's Contributing Author Chuck Black. Part 1 examined historical context on the right to be informed, while this work argues whether such a right should exist.

Part 1 of this series establishes that there are no legal guarantees under US, Canadian, or European Union (EU) laws mandating the "right" to be informed.

US law is rooted in the First Amendment of its Constitution and its restrictions against government abridging the freedom of speech or of the press. Meanwhile, Canadian and EU laws put more weight on protecting people from information the government judges to be "harmful."

What's not established under any of these systems is a broad, positive constitutional or civil right to be "informed," in a way that would obligate any government or private publisher to supply, verify, or guarantee access to accurate, complete, or balanced information.

Being informed isn't a civil right in Western nations. A few laws have come close.

Legal Frameworks

What Do US, Canadian, and EU Laws Guarantee?

United States

First Amendment

  • Free Speech and PressThe government can't abridge speech or the press, and owes no one accurate news

  • FOIA and Sunshine ActAnyone can request federal agency records and attend many agency meetings

  • News Distortion PolicyThe Fairness Doctrine ended in 1987; Only a narrow FCC policy against deliberate news distortion remains

Canada

Charter Section 2(b)

  • Expression With LimitsExpression and the press are protected, subject to reasonable limits under the Oakes test

  • Access to Information ActCitizens, permanent residents, and anyone in Canada can request federal records

  • False News RuleTV licensees can't air false or misleading news; No law requires accurate journalism

European Union

EU Charter and ECHR

  • Expression With LimitsBoth protect the freedom to receive and share information, subject to limits set by law

  • Regulation 1049/2001The public can request EU institution records; Member states set their own rules

  • Media and Platform RulesThe Media Freedom Act protects editorial independence; The DSA makes big platforms assess risks to civic debate

None of the 3 systems gives citizens a right to be informed by accurate journalism

Has the US ever come close to a right to be informed?

In the US, the closest historical comparison is the 1949-1987 Fairness Doctrine, a Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulation which required licensed radio and television broadcasters to cover controversial issues of public importance and present "contrasting" viewpoints.

The doctrine focused only on "balance" and access to differing views, not factual accuracy or a duty to report the "truth" (which multiplicity of voices in itself doesn't guarantee). It covered only over-the-air broadcast licensees (justified by the "spectrum scarcity" of traditional radio and television), not print, cable, or later digital media.

The FCC repealed the doctrine on August 4, 1987, by a unanimous 4 to 0 vote, primarily because the Commission concluded that it chilled speech, no longer served the public interest, and rested on an outdated "scarcity" rationale.

The FCC still maintains a narrow Broadcast News Distortion policy for broadcast licensees, which covers the deliberate distortion or staging of significant events. A finding under this policy requires a high level of proof, including the direct involvement of station management, not ordinary inaccuracies, errors, or differences of opinion.

It's rarely enforced and doesn't apply to cable, print, or online-only outlets. It's a licensing policy, not a criminal law.

How do the US, Canada, and the EU treat harmful speech?

The sharpest legal fights over free speech around the world center on "disinformation," "hate speech," and "harmful but legal" content.

US law doesn't recognize "hate speech" as a legal category that lets the government restrict speech. It allows only narrow, traditional exceptions such as "incitement" ("directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action") and "true threats."

Under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996, online platforms, websites, and other internet users are protected from being held legally responsible for content posted by third parties.

In Canada, Charter protection is subject to "reasonable" limits under the Oakes test, as outlined in Part 1.

Recent Criminal Code and human-rights provisions target certain hateful expressions. Section 319(1) criminalizes the public incitement of hatred, and Section 319(7) defines hatred as "an emotion of an intense and extreme nature that is clearly associated with vilification and detestation." Under that definition, unlike in the US, speech can be prosecuted in Canada for the emotion it promotes.

The EU accepts even broader restrictions on "hate speech" than Canada.

Its 2008 "Framework Decision on combating certain forms and expressions of racism and xenophobia by means of criminal law," along with various national laws, criminalizes specific forms of hate speech. The Digital Services Act (DSA) backs those laws with "platform duties": Platforms like Facebook and X must act on notices of illegal content or face fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual revenue.

The European Convention on Human Rights (Article 10) explicitly allows limits on speech for reasons of national security, territorial integrity or public safety, prevention of disorder or crime, protection of health or morals, protection of reputation or rights of others, preventing disclosure of confidential information, and maintaining judicial authority and impartiality.

Each limit must be "necessary in a democratic society," but that still leaves enough leverage to restrict nearly any public conversation.

Platform Liability

Who Answers for What Users Post?

United States

Section 230

  • Broad ImmunityPlatforms aren't treated as the publisher of what users post

  • Good Samaritan RuleRemoving content in good faith doesn't cost a platform its protection

Canada

No Section 230 Equivalent

  • Common Law DefamationCourts decide platform liability case by case

  • USMCA Article 19.17A trade commitment that limits treating platforms as publishers

  • Notice and NoticePlatforms forward copyright complaints to users

European Union

Digital Services Act

  • Conditional Safe HarborsProtection lasts only while a platform acts on illegal content it knows about

  • No General MonitoringPlatforms can't be ordered to screen every post

  • Risk AssessmentsThe largest platforms must assess and reduce systemic risks

US law grants immunity up front, while EU law makes it conditional on acting against known illegal content

Should being informed be enshrined as a right in national constitutions or the law?

While it's traditionally been considered a "democratic necessity" to have informed citizens who can independently evaluate policies and hold leaders accountable, any positive right to be "informed" requires someone to define what counts as accurate or "sufficient."

Whoever gets to answer that question controls the entire process.

The Debate

Should Being Informed Be a Right?

The Case For

Why Supporters Want a Right

  • Democratic NecessitySelf-government depends on voters who know what's happening

  • Public Good ProblemMarkets underpay for accurate reporting

  • Existing FoundationsAccess to information laws already point this way

  • Complex SocietiesModern policy is too technical to follow unaided

  • EquityReliable news reaches some citizens far more easily than others

The Case Against

Why the Right Would Backfire

  • Free Expression RiskSomeone in government has to define "informed"

  • Practical ImpossibilityNo court can order a citizen to be informed

  • Negative Rights TraditionWestern rights restrain government instead of assigning it duties

  • Market and Voluntary AlternativesPublishers and readers already fill much of the gap

  • Historical CautionMandated truth has a long record of abuse

No major jurisdiction recognizes a general right to be informed by accurate journalism

Which countries already guarantee a right to information?

The risk of defining "informed" hasn't stopped dozens of countries from writing full or partial right-to-information (RTI) clauses into their constitutions.

Counts vary by source and definition, but 78 of 142 rated countries have gone down this path (49 with a full guarantee and 29 with a limited one), according to the Centre for Law and Democracy's global RTI ratings.

Examples include:

  • South Africa's 1996 Constitution (Section 32) is widely regarded as one of the best RTI clauses; It gives everyone the right of access to information held by the state and by private parties when required for the exercise or protection of any rights

  • Mexico's Constitution (Article 6) explicitly guarantees the right of access to information plus freedom of speech unencumbered by judicial or administrative inquisition, unless it transgresses morality, private life, or the rights of a third party, provokes a crime, or disturbs public order

  • Sweden's 1766 Freedom of the Press Act is the world's first law establishing freedom of the press and public access to government documents

  • Finland and Norway both provide explicit constitutional rights of access to public documents

In some countries without an explicit RTI clause, supreme or constitutional courts have interpreted broader free-expression or other rights to include the right of access to information held by public bodies.

Examples frequently cited include Canada, India, and France. 3 things complicate the count:

  • Many countries (including the US and Canada) have long-standing statutory freedom-of-information laws without an explicit constitutional right to information

  • The strength of the constitutional text varies widely: Some are brief references inside free-expression clauses, while others are detailed stand-alone rights with enforcement mechanisms

  • Constitutional status doesn't automatically guarantee effective implementation; That depends on implementing legislation, oversight bodies, and political will

Together, these 3 complications make it hard to draw conclusions from the data provided by the Centre for Law and Democracy.

Do constitutional guarantees make countries freer?

If you cross-reference the current Centre for Law and Democracy Global RTI Ratings against the Freedom House annual listing of Freedom in the World scores, you find that a constitutional right-to-information clause doesn't predict how free a country is.

Freedom in the World scores countries on a 0 to 100 scale based on political rights and civil liberties, classifying them as Free, Partly Free, or Not Free. Freedom House evaluates 195 countries and 13 territories on 25 indicators: 10 for political rights and 15 for civil liberties.

Freedom House Score, 0 to 100

A Constitutional Right to Information Doesn't Predict Freedom

Median score: 66 with a full guarantee, 65 with a partial one, 73 with none

According to the chart:

  • Countries with full constitutional RTI guarantees span the full freedom spectrum and include high-scoring democracies like Finland (100), Sweden (99), Norway (99), and Belgium (95) plus lower-scoring, less free countries like Afghanistan (8), Belarus (7), and South Sudan (0)

  • Countries with partial guarantees show a similar spread with Canada (97), Estonia (96), and the Czech Republic (95) on the high end and Venezuela (13) and Azerbaijan (6) on the low end

  • Many of the world's freest countries, including the US, Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand, and Japan, have long-standing statutory freedom-of-information laws but no explicit constitutional RTI clause, or only a limited one; Conversely, several countries with strong constitutional wording score far lower than those democracies

  • The median Freedom House score is 66 for countries with full guarantees, 65 for partial guarantees, and 73 for countries with no constitutional guarantee at all

The lack of correlation between the 2 lists suggests that a "right to be informed" doesn't, by itself, create a free country with independent citizens able to hold power to account.

There's also no indication that "right to be informed" legislation would obligate any government or private publisher to supply, verify, or guarantee access to accurate, complete, or balanced information.

Therefore, I see no justification for enacting such legislation.

So what does it take to create a free and informed society? It takes citizens who seek information out for themselves, because no constitutional clause has done that work for them. To this day, being informed duly remains a right you practice, not one you're handed.

Have questions about informed.now? Get answers.

Keep reading

Black and white photo of a smiling bearded man in a suit reading his phone by a railing with city towers behind him, with the informed.now logo and the words news without noise

Is being informed a civil right?

Black and white photo of a smiling man with locs and gloves reading his phone by a chain link fence, with the informed.now logo and the words news without noise

Can you stay informed with a dumbphone?

Black and white photo of two people sitting close together on a couch looking at a phone, with the informed.now logo and the words news without noise

What is a news desert, and what happens to a town without local news?

Get factual news by text

Free forever with no bias, clickbait, or ads