# How do news websites make money, and why are paywalls everywhere?

> Paywalls keep appearing on news sites that used to be free, because advertisers stopped paying for reporting and readers inherited the bill. A library card, 1 or 2 chosen subscriptions, and a good summary keep you informed without paying every paywall.

Source: https://informed.now/blog/why-news-sites-have-paywalls

By Kira Shishkin · November 20, 2026 · News Industry

**Summary:** News websites make money from 2 sources: Advertisers and readers. Advertising revenue collapsed, so readers now pay US newspapers more than advertisers do, and a paywall is how a site collects from readers. Paywalls are everywhere because reader revenue is the only stream that has held, even though few people pay.

A paywall is a bill that used to go to someone else. Reporting has always cost money: Salaries, travel, lawyers, and months of work on articles that may never run. For decades advertisers covered most of that cost, and readers paid a small cover price. When advertisers took their money elsewhere, the bill landed on readers.

### Where does a news site's money come from?

A news site sells 2 things. It sells its readers' attention to advertisers, and it sells the reporting itself to readers through subscriptions, memberships, and donations. Events, grants, and wealthy owners help some outlets, but advertisers and readers are the 2 sources that pay for most newsrooms.

The 2 sources pull a newsroom in different directions. An advertiser pays for views, so an ad-funded site earns more whenever more people click, whatever the headline says. That pull toward clicks shapes how news [gets chosen](https://informed.now/blog/how-news-gets-chosen). A subscriber pays for reporting worth returning to, so a reader-funded site earns more when readers trust the work enough to renew.

### Why did advertising stop paying for the news?

Advertisers found ways to reach the same people for less than a newspaper charged. A printed newspaper was once the main route from a local business to a local buyer, and the newspaper priced its pages accordingly. Online, a car dealer or a grocery chain can reach those buyers through search results and social feeds, where ad space never runs out and each ad is aimed at a single person. News pages became a small corner of a much larger market.

US newspaper advertising revenue was an estimated $9.76 billion in 2022, down 5% from $10.26 billion in 2021, according to Pew Research Center's newspapers [fact sheet](https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/newspapers/). In 2005, advertising brought in $49.44 billion.

Moving online didn't rescue the ad business. Digital ads made up 48% of newspaper ad revenue in 2022, up from 17% in 2011, by the same Pew [estimates](https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/newspapers/). The digital share grew while the total kept shrinking.

Newsrooms absorbed the loss. US newsroom employment fell 26% from 2008 to 2020, from 114,000 jobs to 85,000, according to a July 2021 Pew Research Center [analysis](https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2021/07/13/u-s-newsroom-employment-has-fallen-26-since-2008/) of Bureau of Labor Statistics data. Inside that 2008 to 2020 total, newspaper newsrooms shrank 57%, from 71,000 jobs to 31,000, while digital-native newsrooms grew 144%, from 7,400 jobs to 18,000. The digital-native gain of 10,600 jobs replaced about a quarter of the 40,000 newspaper jobs lost.

### Readers now pay more than advertisers, and few readers pay

Reader revenue held while advertising fell. US newspaper circulation revenue, the money readers pay, was $11.61 billion in 2022, up from $11.52 billion in 2021, in the same Pew [fact sheet](https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/newspapers/). Set the $11.61 billion from readers beside the $9.76 billion from advertisers in 2022, and readers are a bigger customer than advertisers.

A paywall follows from those 2 numbers. An outlet that earns more from subscribers than from advertisers protects what subscribers pay for, and the plainest protection is a gate: Read a few articles free, then pay.

Reader revenue is steady, and it's small. The $11.61 billion that readers paid in 2022 comes nowhere near the $49.44 billion that advertisers paid in 2005. Readers kept paying. They didn't fill the hole advertisers left.

Most people don't pay at all. Across 20 richer countries, 18% of people pay for any online news, and 20% do in the US, the Reuters Institute [reported](https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/digital-news-report/2025/dnr-executive-summary) in its Digital News Report 2025. Every paywall rests on that paying minority. Paywalls are everywhere because every outlet faces the same sums: Advertising pays far less than it did in 2005, and subscriber revenue is the line that holds.

### Paywalls do lock out people who can't pay

A paywall sorts readers by income. Careful reporting goes to people who can afford a subscription, and people who can't afford a subscription get whatever is free, including rumor, outrage, and recycled headlines. A public where subscribers get verified reporting and everyone else gets leftovers stops sharing the same facts.

That objection is right, and we can't argue it away. A reader who can't afford any subscription gets less reporting than a subscriber gets, and the free options don't close that gap.

The free options are better than the objection assumes, though. Public broadcasters publish their reporting at no charge, many public libraries offer cardholders digital access to newspapers, metered paywalls let a fixed number of articles through each month, and many outlets send free newsletters written by their own reporters.

Free news also has a payer. Taxpayers and donors fund a public broadcaster. Advertisers fund most free sites, and what advertisers buy is the reader's attention, so reading [without ads](https://informed.now/blog/news-without-ads) usually means the reader pays instead. Reporting cost money long before the first paywall, and reporting that nobody pays for stops getting made. The 57% [drop](https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2021/07/13/u-s-newsroom-employment-has-fallen-26-since-2008/) in newspaper newsroom jobs from 2008 to 2020 shows how much reporting has already stopped.

### How can you stay informed without paying for every paywall?

Nobody needs to pay every paywall. Split your reading into 4 parts:

1. **Pick 1 or 2 outlets worth paying for.** Choose the outlets whose reporting you'd miss most, often a local paper and a national or specialist outlet. Your money goes straight to newsrooms you rely on.
2. **Use a library card.** Many public libraries give cardholders free digital access to newspapers and magazines, so check your library's website before buying another subscription.
3. **Spend metered free articles deliberately.** A metered paywall lets a fixed number of articles through each month. Save those articles for reporting you can't find elsewhere, and skip the headlines every outlet carries.
4. **Choose a summary for the rest.** A [news digest](https://informed.now/blog/what-is-a-news-digest) covers the day's main events in a few minutes, so your subscriptions and your free articles go toward depth. A public broadcaster's bulletin or an outlet's free morning newsletter does the job.

Our version of Step 4 is [informed.now](https://informed.now), which sends 6 news summaries by text message, picked with one transparent filter. It's one text every weekday morning.

### Every news source has a payer

A paywall makes the payer visible, and every free page has one too: A subscriber, a taxpayer, a donor, or an advertiser buying attention. Find out who pays for each source you read, and you'll know whom that source answers to.
